The Symptoms of Interference: Review of Political Influence in Policing
Keywords:
Gender, propensity score matching, Youth, Chile, NEET, poverty household, corruption, Political influence, Law enforcement, Oversight mechanisms, and Governance failuresAbstract
The nexus between political influence, corruption, and governance failures within law enforcement and the criminal justice system is a classic example of the government not being strong but fat. Corruption is a key focus of how political power and vested interests manipulate law enforcement policies, criminalising specific activities while safeguarding influential minority groups. The analysis reveals the symptoms of undetected shady corrupt public officials and lobby groups in establishing police protection rackets, creating a cycle of corruption that benefits various stakeholders and sustains the status quo. Token interventions, such as occasional police raids or prosecutions, are shown to be superficial efforts aimed at placating public concerns without effectively addressing the entrenched corruption. The ever-mounting corruption cases and numbers detail how the criminal justice system’s resources are hypnotised. This article further examines the role of oversight bodies like the Civilian Secretariat for Police and the Portfolio Committee on Police in curbing corruption within the South African Police Service (SAPS). However, it finds that political interference, exemplified by cases involving high-ranking officials, continues to impede monitoring efforts. This underscores the broader implications of corruption, including threats to national security, economic instability, and deepening social inequality. It concludes by advocating for enhanced oversight and comprehensive reform to rebuild trust in governance and uphold the rule of law.
References
Robert L. Akers, C.S. Sellers (2013) Criminological theories: Introduction, evaluation, application.
John W. Creswell (2007) Qualitative inquiry & research design: Choosing among five approaches.
Paul Davis, Peter Francis (2018) Doing criminological research.
Colin Dawson (2002) Practical research methods: A user-friendly guide to mastering research and projects.
C. R. Kothari (2004) Research methodology: Methods and techniques.
J. Mouton (2004) How to succeed in your master's and doctoral studies.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2015) Consequences of Corruption at the Sector Level and Implications for Economic Growth and Development.
Trevor Prenzler (2009) Police corruption: Preventing misconduct and maintaining integrity.
Todor Tagarev (2010) Building integrity and reducing corruption in Defence: A compendium of best practices.
Michael Shaw (2019) South Africa: origins of the mafia state-political transition, organised crime and the impact on democracy.
A. M. Tripp, S. Straus (2024) The Colonial Legacy of Policing as State Building. 78-98.
Corruption Watch (2021) Daring to Act: Perceptions on Whistle-blowing in South Africa. https://www.corruptionwatch.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Whistle _Corruption-Whach_FINAL_9Dec2021.pdf
eNews Channel Africa (2021) Riah Phiyega talks on the tough top cop job. https://www.enca.com/videos/watch-riah-phiyega-talks-tough-top-cop-job
Koko Koko (2019) Suspended ex-top cop Phahlane earns R4 million while on ‘paid holiday’. https://www.iol.co.za/amp/the-star/news/suspended-ex-top-cop-phahlane-earns-r4m-while-on-paid-holiday-39116542
M. Kwinika (2019) An Analytical Assessment of Police Killings in South Africa. https://irpcdn.multiscreensite.com/078aba73/files/uploaded/Presentation%20on%20Police%20Murders.pdf
K. Mabelane (2021) SSA offered journalists bribes, commission hears. https://www.power987.co.noclick.za/featured/ssa-offered-journalists-bribes-commission-hears/?s=09
C. Mthethwa (2020) Two senior Hawks officials, former cop arrested for alleged fraud and corruption. https://www.news24.co/news24/southafrica/news/two-senior-hawks-officials-former-cop-arrested-for-alleged-fraud-and-corruption-20201110
S. Mtshali (2021) General Khehla Sitole: Is being National Police Commissioner a poisoned chalice?. https://www.iol.co.za/news/politics/general-khehla-sitole-is-being-national-police-commissioner-a-poisoned-chalice-8f41f6d8-877a-484d-979c-7b9a37fb2868
B. Pillay (2024) R1.6 billion paid by SAPS for wrongful arrests over 4 years, Mzansi wants accountability. https://www.msn.com/en-za/news/other/r1-6-billion-paid-by-saps-for-wrongful-arrests-over-past-4-years-mzansi-wants-accountability/ar-AA1w2BGO?ocid=winp2fptaskbar&cvid=af86abc580cb45d1b04f2721b5223f9f&ei=29
S. Seboka (2021) Multi-million police lights corruption case postponed to June. https://www.npa.gov.za/site/default/files/media-releases/MULTI-MILLION%20POLICE%20BLUE%20LIGHTS%20CORRUPTION%20CASE%20POSTPONED%20TO%20JUNE.pdf
S. Sibiya (2024) Gangs make us pay for access to water, say Mamelodi residents. https://groundup.org.za/article/eight-suspects-in-court-for-allegedly-extorting-residents-at-government-owned-flats-in-mamelodi/
The Presidency (2022) President Cyril Ramaphosa: Announcement of National Commissioner. https://www.gov.za/speeches/president-cyril-ramaphosa-announcement-ational-commissioner-police-31-mar-2022-0000
V. Basdeo (2010) The curse of corruption in the South African Police: A rot from within. 23(3), 385-400.
M. P. Bhandari (2023) The corruption a chronic disease of humanity: Causes, effects and consequences. 27(1), 5-17.
J. Berning, M. Montesh (2012) Countering corruption in South Africa: The rise and fall of the Scorpions and the Hawks. 3-10.
M. E. Brogden, P. Nijhar (1998) Corruption and the South African Police. 30, 89-06.
D. Bruce (2013) A provincial concern? Political killings in South Africa. 45, 13-24.
J. Burger (2011) To protect and serve: Restoring public confidence in the SAPS. 36, 13-22.
N. F. Campos, F. Giovannoni (2007) Lobbying, corruption and political influence. 131, 1-2.
L. De Haven-Smith, M. T. Witt (2009) Preventing state crimes against democracy. 41(5), 527-550.
S. J. Evenett (2002) The impact of economic sanctions on South African exports. 49, 557-573.
A. Faull (2007) Corruption and the South African Police Service. A review and its implications. 150, 1-20.
A. Faull (2011) Oversight agencies in South Africa and the challenge of police corruption. 227, 1-17.
S. Ivković Kutnjak, A. Sauerman (2015) Threading the thin blue line: Transition towards democratic policing and the integrity of the South African Police Service. 25(1), 25-52.
A. K. Jain (2001) Corruption: A review. 15(1), 71-121.
A. Kumssa (2015) Police corruption: A perspective on its nature and control. 1(1), 001-008.
B. Lessing (2020) Conceptualizing criminal governance. 19(3), 1-20.
G. Newham, A. Faull (2011) Protector or predator: Tackling police corruption in South Africa.
G. Newham, L. Gomomo (2003) Bad cops get a break: The closure of the SAPS anti-Corruption Unit. 4, 5-9.
G. Newham (2002) Tackling police corruption in South Africa. 1-19.
J.G.J. Nortje (2023) The protection of whistleblowers in South African criminal cases. 30(6), 1444-1457.
R. Peters (1991) Political Interference with the Police. Is it Something New?. 64(2), 96-103.
S. Pillay (2004) Corruption—the challenge to good governance: A South African perspective. 17(7), 586–605.
J. Steinberg (2014) Policing, state power, and the transition from apartheid to democracy: A new perspective. 113(451), 173–191.
A. Sundström (2015) Covenants with broken swords: Corruption and law enforcement in governance of the Commons. 31, 253–62.
K. D. Tunnell (1993) Political crime and pedagogy: A content analysis of criminology and criminal justice texts. 4(1), 101–114.
K. D. Tunnell, L. K. Gaines (1992) Political pressures and influences on police executives: descriptive analysis. 11(1), 1-16.
H. Williams (2002) Core factors of police corruption across the world. 2(1), 85-99.
S. Grootes (2019) As the Zondo revelations grow ever more shocking, we risk sliding into cynicism and somnambulance. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2019-09-30-as-the-zondo-revelations-grow-ever-more-shocking-we-risk-sliding-into-cynicism-and-somnambulance/
M. Thamm (2020) Disgraced Khomotso Phahlane loses Labour Court appeal against dismissal from SAPS. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2020-08-12-disgraced-khomotso-phahlane-loses-labour-court-appeal-against-dismissal-from-saps/
M. Thamm (2021) SAPS PPE scandal: Clash of top brass amid claims of massive corruption. https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-01-17-saps-ppe-scandal-clash-of-top-bras
J. Burger (2016) Political interference weakening the rule of law in SA.
Department of Public Service and Administration (2003) Country Corruption Assessment Report: South Africa. 1-148.
B. Minyuku (1998) Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa: Volume 1.
South African Police Service (2017) Annual Report 2016/2017.
South African Police Service (2023) Annual Report 2012/2013.
Transparency International (2023) Corruption Perceptions Index. Time to end impunity for corruption. https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2023
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Authors and Global Journals Private Limited
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
